In the section we analyze the lifecycle costs of battery storage systems, focusing on total cost of ownership (TCO) and return on investment (ROI) metrics.?

​

There are three system options (Basic, Mid-level, Large) and two scenarios (with and without various incentives).

​

Summary:  

​

Without consideration of incentives (representative cash flow) - Key insights from this lifecycle analysis:

​

1. Economies of scale are significant - larger systems have better economics per kWh despite higher absolute costs.

2. The sweet spot for ROI appears to be in the mid-range systems (around 27 kWh), balancing:

   • Installation efficiency

   • Operational costs

   • Revenue potential

   • Component replacement timing

3. Component replacement strategy is crucial:

   • Inverter replacement timing can significantly impact TCO

   • Battery module failures increase substantially after warranty period

   • Preventive maintenance can extend component life and improve ROI

​

With consideration of incentives (using Boulder County, Colorado as representative geographic location) - Key insights from this lifecycle analysis:

​

​​

1. Substantial utility incentives through Xcel Energy's (the local utility) battery storage program

2. Local EnergySmart rebates (County Program)

3. State tax benefits

4. Federal tax incentives

​

The combination of these benefits transforms the economics, making even the basic system financially viable and the larger systems significantly profitable over their lifecycle. Key observations:

​

1. Payback periods are reduced by more than 50%

2. IRR increases to levels competitive with many other investments

3. Larger systems become even more attractive due to economies of scale in installation and better capture of available incentives

​

​

Battery Storage System Lifecycle Cost Analysis

(15-Year Period)

Initial Capital Costs

​

Hardware Costs (By System Size)

​

1. Basic System (13.5 kWh)

   • Battery unit: $8,500

   • Inverter: $3,000

   • Monitoring system: $500

   • Total: $12,000

2. Mid-Range System (27 kWh)

   • Battery units: $17,000

   • Inverter: $4,500

   • Monitoring system: $500

   • Total: $22,000

3. Large System (40.5 kWh)

   • Battery units: $25,500

   • Inverter: $6,000

   • Monitoring system: $500

   • Total: $32,000

Installation Costs

​

• Basic electrical work: $2,500

• Panel upgrades: $2,000

• Permits and inspections: $500

• Labor (varies by system size):

  • Basic: $3,000

  • Mid-Range: $4,500

  • Large: $6,000

Operational Costs (Annual)

​

Energy Losses

​

• Round-trip efficiency losses: 10-15%

• Annual cost impact (@$0.15/kWh):

  • Basic: $150

  • Mid-Range: $300

  • Large: $450

Maintenance Costs

​

1. Preventive Maintenance

   • Annual inspection: $200

   • Firmware updates: $100

   • System cleaning: $150

   • Total: $450/year

2. Component Replacement

   • Inverter replacement (Year 10): $3,000-6,000

   • Battery module replacements:

     • Years 1-5: Covered by warranty

     • Years 6-10: 2% failure rate ($500/year avg)

     • Years 11-15: 5% failure rate ($1,200/year avg)

Degradation Impact

​

Capacity Loss

​

• Annual degradation: 2.5%

• Cumulative capacity loss:

  • Year 5: 12%

  • Year 10: 23%

  • Year 15: 32%

Financial Impact

​

• Replacement power costs (@$0.15/kWh):

  • Basic: $75/year increasing to $180/year

  • Mid-Range: $150/year increasing to $360/year

  • Large: $225/year increasing to $540/year

Revenue/Savings Streams

​

Peak Load Shifting

​

Annual savings:

• Basic: $800-1,000

• Mid-Range: $1,600-2,000

• Large: $2,400-3,000

Demand Response Programs

​

Annual revenue:

• Basic: $500

• Mid-Range: $1,000

• Large: $1,500

Backup Power Value

​

(Based on avoided outage costs)

• Residential value: $150/day of outage

• Annual expected value:

  • Basic: $450 (3 events/year)

  • Mid-Range: $900 (6 events/year)

  • Large: $1,350 (9 events/year)

​

Side-by-Side Analysis Results

The summary results of this analysis are tabulated and presented below: